Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: Knotty Apes


I am the Jammie King!




Status: Offline
Posts: 12736
Date: Jun 17, 2005
Knotty Apes


One for Copper, seeing as she is our resident expert in all things apey.


Can apes untie knots?


An offhand comment by a mate last night developed into a minor debate about the ability of apes to untie knots.  The cable of his x-box was all tangled an knotted, so I made some disparaging comment about it.  He then told me, knowledgably, that the ability to untie knots was linked to one's intelligence and that it was one of the many things that set us apart from apes - they are, apparently, not clever enough to get their heads around it.


I quite reasonably pointed out however that his opinion on the subject was a load of old cobblers and that it would just be stoopid to believe something as silly as that.  Of course apes can untie knots.  Duh.


So what I need here is a bit of authoritative backup, Copp.  Tell me I'm right.  Or at the very least, give me a get-out clause that doesn't make me look like a berk.



__________________
The King has spoken... But nobody listened.


Superhero Extraordinaire


Status: Offline
Posts: 593
Date: Jun 17, 2005

ddvmor wrote:


 He then told me, knowledgably, that the ability to untie knots was linked to one's intelligence and that it was one of the many things that set us apart from apes -


Ok.  Firstly let me reiterate that human beings are scientifically classified as apes. 


As for the knots, I am sure that knot complexity and 'intelligence' are correlated (along with dexterity), and as such some species of primate can untie them and others can't.  I have seen chimps untie knots, and have no doubt that most apes can untie simple knots (probably not complicated ones, but then again, most people can't either - hence the cable discussion). 




__________________
Blast it.


I am the Jammie King!




Status: Offline
Posts: 12736
Date: Jun 17, 2005

Copper wrote:


Ok.  Firstly let me reiterate that human beings are scientifically classified as apes. 


Hah.  Semantics are a wonderful thing, eh!


Thank you for your clarification.   As I suspected, I was right.  I like being right.  I try to be right as often as I can, just for that smugness that I can experience immediately afterwards!



__________________
The King has spoken... But nobody listened.


Superhero Extraordinaire


Status: Offline
Posts: 593
Date: Jun 17, 2005


ddvmor wrote:





Copper wrote:Firstly let me reiterate that human beings are scientifically classified as apes.  Hah. 


Semantics are a wonderful thing, eh!



Would you quibble about rats and mice both being rodents?  Geese and ducks both being birds?


There are 5 genera of ape (maybe more, but lets not split hairs) - gorillas, chimps/bonobos, orangutans, gibbons and humans.  Fact. 



__________________
Blast it.


I am the Jammie King!




Status: Offline
Posts: 12736
Date: Jun 17, 2005

Copper wrote:


Would you quibble about rats and mice both being rodents?  Geese and ducks both being birds?


Of course I would.  It's my god-given right to quibble over every little thing.  If i can't quibble over the facts of your statement, I'll simply attempt to discredit it by taking apart the grammatical structure of the statement and make dodgy assessments of your character based on my own flawed and somewhat bigoted opinions.  Like this:


Rats?  Plural.  Mice?  Plural.  There are clearly more than one of each being referred to in your statement, yet you use the word 'both'.  'Both' implies two or a pair.  Which means that either you can't count or you simply don't fully understand the English language.  Either way, it suggests that you are unqualified to lecture me on science.  I believe Dean Yaeger said it best: "Your theories are the worst kind of popular tripe, your methods are sloppy and your conclusions are highly questionable." (extra credit to whoever can place the quote!)


Or something along those lines.  Obviously I wouldn't really do this to you as I'm far too nice a guy!



Copper wrote:


There are 5 genera of ape (maybe more, but lets not split hairs) - gorillas, chimps/bonobos, orangutans, gibbons and humans.  Fact. 


Remind me which one I am, again...?



__________________
The King has spoken... But nobody listened.


I ain't a Pirate and I ain't called Anne, but I sure am Bonnie!

(Mrs)





Status: Offline
Posts: 3266
Date: Jun 17, 2005


ddvmor wrote:

I believe Dean Yaeger said it best: "Your theories are the worst kind of popular tripe, your methods are sloppy and your conclusions are highly questionable." (extra credit to whoever can place the quote!)




crap.. who am i going to call?

__________________
current location: Antrim. I like it.


Superhero Extraordinaire


Status: Offline
Posts: 593
Date: Jun 17, 2005

ddvmor wrote:


Rats?  Plural.  Mice?  Plural.  There are clearly more than one of each being referred to in your statement, yet you use the word 'both'. 


I am clearly referring to each as a category.  Therefore, I can refer to 'both' categories quite happily.


You, Darren, are a pedant. 


And a pedant who shouldn't post threads about apes/monkeys/evolution/psychology without being fully prepared to air your unfortunate creationist leanings...


 



__________________
Blast it.


I am the Jammie King!




Status: Offline
Posts: 12736
Date: Jun 17, 2005

A pedant, eh?  And I thought you were gonna say 'Gibbon'.  So you're saying I'm not an ape.  So what classification does a pedant come under then, oh wise and cleverish one?


Oh yeah... and I only support creationism cos I always root for the underdog!  Hah!



-- Edited by ddvmor at 15:23, 2005-06-17

__________________
The King has spoken... But nobody listened.


Vice JDK
and Man of the People





Status: Offline
Posts: 5453
Date: Jun 17, 2005

bonniepirateanne wrote:



crap.. who am i going to call?



Not C.B.G.B's; I aint got time for that now!


G.B.s?



-- Edited by NateO at 21:48, 2005-06-17

__________________
You can't polish a turd
Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard