Members Login
Username 
 
Password 
    Remember Me  
Post Info TOPIC: Occupy The Bored Board.


I am the Jammie King!




Status: Offline
Posts: 12736
Date: Oct 28, 2011
Occupy The Bored Board.


So the 'Occupy' movement had been occupying for a few weeks now. Could someone explain to my what they're occupying for?

I've seen a few things on the news and the internet about it, including interviews with the protesters; but nothing has really enlightened me beyond 'capitalists teh baaaad'.

A Google search for their demands just comes up with phrases like 'Some people have criticised the Occupy movement for having vague or no demands'; 'There are no Official Demands of the Occupy Movement'; 'Occupy group in Maine said, “I don't think we should issue a list of demands at all"'.

I'm fully supportive of the right of people to demonstrate about stuff, but I'd like them to be clear about what they're demonstrating for. I thought the whole point of demonstrating is to get your point across. Otherwise, you're just standing around, doing nothing. Which is the exact opposite of demonstrating.

I went to school with a guy with who's now a bit of a hippie (the macbook owning, latte swilling middle-class type) and posts quite a lot of self righteous activisty stuff on facebook. He mentioned a week or so back that he was heading out to join the protest, so I took the opportunity to ask him. The conversation went like this:

Hippie Chris: This is it Ladies and Gents. The big one is here! (Link to news video about Occupy London)

JDK: Remind me again what they're actually occupying for...?

Hippie Chris: they don't know yet. that's the whole point. They're designing threir own demands democratically. Sadly that approach isn't being conveyed well by the BBC et al so your best bet is to follow the coverage across the web. I suspect it may involve some of universal debt jubilee where debts are written off by govt-created debt-free money.

JDK: Seems to me that it might be sensible to have an agenda BEFORE they start demonstrating rather then... eventually!

Hippie Chris: Nope, not at all. If someone or other writes an agenda in advance, then what if lots of the people there don't agree with it? Rather better to work one out once everyone arrives. I for one will be popping down there this week to add in my tuppence worth. At this point, I was at a crossroads. I could give up in exasperation, attempt some sort of intelligent discourse, or take the piss. I decided on a compromise by taking the piss, but kind, sorta making a vague point. Mostly I expected to be ignored:

JDK: It kinda sounds to me like the perfect way to piss everyone off without letting them know why thery're being pissed off. By the time everyone's agreed what to piss people off about, people will just be pissed off and piss off, leving the demonstrators with no-one to piss off, and getting pissed off themselves. Am I missing something?

Hippie Chris: Possibly... :P

Hippie Chris: I don't know. You might be right

Hippie Chris: But I've been involved in a few really well-facilitated working groups like the ones they're running and it can be really good.

Hippie Chris (about an hour later): Of course people can get "pissed off" but it appears to be working in spain. take a look at this price in Energy Bulletin and make your own mind up: http://www.energybulletin.net/stories/2011-10-17/talk-amongst-yourselves

I read, it, but it was largely wishy-washy inclusive nonsense, which, it seems to me, is representative of the whole Occupy cult... er... Movement. So, yeah. they're still occupying. But why?



__________________
The King has spoken... But nobody listened.


Old.
But wise!





Status: Offline
Posts: 1524
Date: Oct 28, 2011

Without wasting a lot of life's remaining time, I've made a couple of observations about them:

It appears to be a collection of the great unwashed gathering in the great outdoors much to the relief of us who occupy the indoors with our indoor plumbing...

I've seen some videos of them chanting after their "leader" says something through a megaphone...I suppose they've started their own cult...

It also appears that the laws governing trespassing have been suspended...wary...Ben



__________________
"It must be mounted on a tripod!...It must be mounted on a tripod!" - Cmdr. Frederick Mohr


Teiam Member




Status: Offline
Posts: 2078
Date: Oct 28, 2011

People are down there for a lot of reasons -- some relevant, some not (whenever you get a large group of people, there will always be the ones out there trying to push their own cause even if it has nothing at all to do with the central message). I have friends that have been down in the city since the beginning. Some come and go, spend a weekend, then come back. I'd be down there but given the random outbreaks of brutality and violence aimed at protestors, I can't risk it right now (I was randomly in Times Square right before the protest moved up there, and the police were there in riot gear with zip ties and batons at the ready). They're not all members of "the great unwashed". A lot of them are honest, decent people who are tired of getting shit on by supposed "representatives" that have been bought and paid for. They are people who HAVE looked for jobs -- have spent MONTHS doing so and despite all of the protection for "job creators" there are no jobs to be had. Did you know that many business are outright saying "unemployed need not apply"? That unless you already have a job, you're not getting one from them? At 53 years old my father was let go from a job that he had given his heart and soul to for 15 years. Why? As an example to the rest of the employees that if they could let someone like HIM go, NONE of them were safe. His wife was laid off from her job a few months later. They have a mortgage, and car payments, and expenses and THANKFULLY were able to find work after a few months so they weren't in the hole too badly. But they were LUCKY. They don't live above their means, they are just trying to survive -- but there are people out there who tell them that somehow they deserved it, or they didn't try hard enough or save enough or blahblahblah bootstraps. My brother is an epileptic who has to hope that he doesn't get laid off or fired and have to go without benefits. He can't afford to pay for his medication out of pocket. Yet, there are candidates up there who say if you don't have health insurance, you should just do everyone a favor and die. Conditions are getting worse, not better, and this is a reaction to that. People are upset, and angry and are feeling abandoned by their government. That's why they (or at least most of them) are down there.

This opinion piece on CNN.com explains it a bit as well: http://www.cnn.com/2011/10/05/opinion/rushkoff-occupy-wall-street/index.html



__________________
*~*Mouth Breathing DVD Extra Watcher*~*


Old.
But wise!





Status: Offline
Posts: 1524
Date: Oct 28, 2011

Jackie, you alluded to a "central message" and that's the part I'm having a hard time with, there doesn't seem to be one...Or maybe I'm too obtuse to see it...

If it's about jobs and the lack threof, getting mad about it and showing how destructive and disruptive one can be is not the way to solve the problem...Innovation and ingenuity will go a lot farther in putting groceries on the table than milling about with others who have nothing better to do than wring their hands and bemoan their fate...

If its about waiting for the government to do something, then the answer is they've caused enough trouble already by spending us into a hole...Let free enterprise work as it's supposed to and get the economy moving...As a businessman, I've always understood that money is worthless unless it's circulating...I can't get rich unless I spend what I've earned to generate more income...

I was 50 when I quit a good-paying career to start my own business, and even if I hadn't found success I wouldn't have known until I tried...I certainly sympathize with your Dad and everyone else who's out of work, but I assure you the opportunities are there to those who open their eyes and try...smile...Ben



__________________
"It must be mounted on a tripod!...It must be mounted on a tripod!" - Cmdr. Frederick Mohr


Teiam Member




Status: Offline
Posts: 2078
Date: Oct 28, 2011

My dad had his own business, had it for years and was doing well, when things just went to shit, he had to file bankruptcy and almost lost everything. He's got no end of "bootstrappiness" but sometimes stuff just doesn't work out. He's not looking for hand outs. Are there people that are? Yes, but I know too many people who through no fault of their own had the great American Dream ripped out from under them and are just trying to survive.

The central message -- at least as far as I choose to understand it -- is that money should NEVER be more important than people.

__________________
*~*Mouth Breathing DVD Extra Watcher*~*


I am the Jammie King!




Status: Offline
Posts: 12736
Date: Oct 29, 2011

Then why don't they just say that? All this vagueness is surely just alienating everyone who doesn't know what that is. Which seems to be pretty much anyone who isn't taking part and about 90% of the participants.

As I said, I'm all for people protesting about stuff they feel strongly about - its an important part of the democratic process - but starting a protest without a specific message in mind seems pointless.

I have a lot of friends in the same boat as your family and friends and have been in pretty much constant danger of being there myself for the last couple of years (and, indeed for the foreseeable future as restructures continue), so have a lot of sympathy. But they're obviously giving people the wrong impression.

__________________
The King has spoken... But nobody listened.


I am the Jammie King!




Status: Offline
Posts: 12736
Date: Oct 29, 2011

By the way, what exactly is the Great American Dream? Is it the one where you're flying through the clouds and then you realise that you forgot to get dressed and then everyone's laughing at you and all your teeth fall out and you realise that you're in a big lime flavoured jelly rabbit and eat you way out?

__________________
The King has spoken... But nobody listened.


Teiam Member




Status: Offline
Posts: 2078
Date: Oct 29, 2011

Cherry, not lime.. but yes exactly!

__________________
*~*Mouth Breathing DVD Extra Watcher*~*


Old.
But wise!





Status: Offline
Posts: 1524
Date: Oct 29, 2011

It's like he's inside my head!...insanity...Ben



__________________
"It must be mounted on a tripod!...It must be mounted on a tripod!" - Cmdr. Frederick Mohr
Page 1 of 1  sorted by
 
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard